Image One – Draft 1

In order to get a solid grasp on how I’ll convey meaning in each image, I think it’s important to really flesh out the logistics of making them, and the academic contexts behind them. But first, I’ll need some kick-off ideas.



Inspired by Benjamin’s theory of ‘aura’, I’m interested in the question of whether a digital experience of an event constitutes reality or vicarious experience; ie, when we turn our phones on to film our family opening their Christmas presents, are we really experiencing it first-hand, or does the incorporation of an intermediary mode take away from the event’s aura?

I think a good way to contextualise this question is to frame it in an apt and familiar philosophical symbol – Plato’s Allegory of the Cave. Here, Plato conjures the image of slaves eternally forced to face a wall upon which shadows dance. These shadows constitute their way of viewing the movements of the real world behind them. He uses this to demonstrate that mistakenness occurs when we only see a representation of the true image. Benjamin concedes that representations of things remove from their value, or their aura. Yet with our post-postmodernist epistemology, especially our firm distrust of objectivity, is this such a fundamentally wrong way of seeing the world?

So, my plan is to update the allegory for our modern context, thereby parodying our culture of hiding behind phones. To do this, I’ll replace the reflective cave wall with a camera on selfie mode. The slaves of the allegory will be swapped with a person taking the selfie, smiling into the camera while their background is smudged and blurred. The background itself – consisting of the silhouettes made to play against the cave walls in the original story – now will present important life events in the selfie-taker’s life.

This first draft is just a quick sketch planning the structure of my digital image. It took a bit of time to decide how I should frame it to include all elements of the cave scenario (the reflection, the person regarding that reflection, and the silhouettes to be reflected). Most visual representations take a side-long perspective, eliminating one of these key elements. To avoid this, I decided on a z-axis perspective, thereby placing the components in background, midground and foreground respectively.


One thought on “Image One – Draft 1

  1. Riona Day says:

    The concept behind this idea is really intriguing and your approach to Plato’s theory allows the audience to feel like they are within the image. However, the intent is a bit lost along the way. I understand that this is a draft but maybe incorporating text, much like that of Plato’s work, would help define what you’re aiming to convey. Maybe adding a satirical title would add to the parody? I like the idea that you can’t see some of the individuals faces and only the selfie, it adds to the idea of how we only see a representation of an image.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s